Saturday, December 6, 2025

Readers Write In #897: Agatha Christie


By Rahini David

I’ve remained an enormous fan of Agatha Christie for some 30 years and until date there is no such thing as a one I might relatively flip to as a weekend alternative. For years, I might go to the library and stare in any respect the classics and their unbelievable blurbs and the large fats romance sagas and the racy thrillers and at last when it was time to borrow there was all the time an AC novel that I introduced house.

What has all the time fascinated me was that AC’s books had been soothing regardless of the daggers and the poisoned espresso and all of the deceptions. The novels stay mind puzzles, even when the characters are being fleshed out. Oh, scratch that. Perhaps that was it. The characters had been virtually by no means fleshed out in my thoughts; they had been detailed however remained delightfully intricate cardboard cutouts. They remained tropes. The gold-digger spouse of the millionaire, the spoilt actress, the hard-working nurse and so forth.

After we watch a film or learn a novel, we’re known as to develop a sure affection for the characters. When studying a thriller, everybody stays a suspect and that makes it like a recreation of chess with the creator and so subconsciously the viewer/reader retains their distance from everybody. One way or the other this itself makes me relate to the characters. The logic appears to movement backward, doesn’t it? However that’s how it’s with me.

I hardly relate to romance novels are we’re known as to narrate to the feminine protagonist and drool over her male love-interest. I virtually really feel a “who’re you to inform me what’s engaging” defiance when studying such books, however whilst I learn an AC novel, I begin rooting for a few characters right here and there and after they change into the killer… it’s so satisfying that’s it unreal. Why? As a result of it’s a magic trick. It’s extra satisfying when AC wins than once I win. It’s the identical if you find yourself concentrating on the magician’s sleeve, however the rabbit seems fully elsewhere.

I’ve admittedly learn solely 4-5 thriller novels that aren’t AC and that too not very lately. And I’ve deserted a number of. If the author can’t make the premise or characters intriguing within the first 50 pages or so, then I’ve no downside placing a guide down and I virtually all the time end an AC guide that I began.

The Humor

One thing that all the time surprises me about AC is her humor. On the finish of every novel Hercule Poirot has a kind of summation gatherings the place all of the suspects are known as right into a room and Poirot explains each clue and the way it helped him arrive on the reality, it’s lengthy, but it surely holds your curiosity and … it stays humorous. Within the first novel I ever learn as a 16-year-old, he tells every suspect why he suspected them within the first place and why he lastly acquitted them in his thoughts, then when he’s doing the identical to the killer, he asks “When did you acquit me?” and Poirot says “By no means, you’re the killer”, I didn’t notice what was occurring till the final phrase hit me and when it did, sure, it stunned and shocked me, but it surely tickled me relatively than horrified me. That sleight of hand, that tickle, and that snigger is what units her aside.

The Recurring Characters

Hercule Poirot is by far my favourite recurring character in any sequence. And his quirks like neatness in logic (and all the pieces else) are properly consistent with his potential to search out an incongruence. Whether or not it’s his place in England as a humorous foreigner who just isn’t as intimidating to the home workers because the uniformed officers or because the understanding outdated man who appears extra like a relationship marketing consultant than the rest however retains studying between the strains and submitting away the data in his thoughts diligently, Poirot is one of the best. It’s a pity that AC began to see him as unbearable, and I’m not one who sees unbearable characters (suppose Hugh Laurie as Dr. Home) as lovely on the whole. However his character appeared to only higher as he went alongside. Solely lately did I learn all the pieces else did I strive Curtains his final case. It’s a bizarre one however in some way, I appreciated it much more than I believed I might.

One way or the other Jane Marple just isn’t fairly the identical for me. The Marple books are good. However they lack the flourish of the denouement and Marple’s superpower is simply being reminded of another person who advised an identical lie and in some way, it isn’t the identical. I would favor a standalone like The Pale Horse to a Marple Novel, and that goes for the others. Inspector Battles books are like standalones anyway as he appears too generic a police inspector to be thought of an actual recurring character. I’ve not learn any Tommy or Tuppence to this point. And Parker Pyne was plainly boring.

The fanbase

The AC fanbase is past age group, or any demographic in any respect. That’s one thing I maintain noticing in AC podcasts, and I additionally hear that the fanbase is kind of forgiving to those that have solely seen the flicks and haven’t learn the books. However it’s most likely due to the big variety of people that like her books that we simply can’t discover one other one who charges the books in the identical approach. I discovered The Hole to be a horrible guide, however different followers appear to love it quite a bit.

Why do folks not like her Nursery Rhymes themed books? Aside from And Then There have been None, which all people appears to adore, folks on-line typically appear to suppose her 5 Little Pigs and Pocketful of Rye and Crooked Home to be very foolish premises, the extra outlandish the premise she chooses, the higher I just like the guide. Generally it could not land, however on the whole I like them.

The one downside I’ve with AC books is that she didn’t age properly, her books aged so properly that even a Gen Alpha would love her work, however in her 80s she wrote substandard books. However once I learn Elephants Can Bear in mind, I simply forgive her for I do know what greatness she is able to. I solely fear about those that begin on the mistaken place. In case you begin on the proper place, it is sort of a journey into an empire.

Related Articles

Latest Articles